A three-member panel of the Court of Appeal in Abuja on Monday reserved judgment on two appeals filed by the Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) and its deputy director, Kolawole Oluwadare, challenging a High Court order that they pay N100 million in damages for defaming two Department of State Services operatives.
Justice Danlami Senchi led the panel, which reserved the matter after all parties adopted their final written addresses. The appeals, marked CA/ABJ/CV/1114/2026 and CA/ABJ/CV/1105/2026, seek to overturn the May 5 judgment of Justice Yusuf Halilu of the Federal Capital Territory High Court.
Counsel for the appellants, Paul Mgbenwa and Oluwatosin Adesioye, urged the court to allow the appeals and set aside the High Court decision. The respondents’ team, led by Akinolu Kehinde, SAN, asked the court to dismiss the appeals for lacking merit. The panel said it would notify the parties of the judgment date.
The High Court had held that SERAP and Oluwadare defamed DSS personnel Sarah John and Gabriel Ogundele through publications on September 9, 2024.
The court found that statements on SERAP’s website and X account falsely claimed the operatives invaded the organisation’s Abuja office and harassed a staff member. Justice Halilu described the publications as being in bad taste and ordered SERAP to pay N100 million in damages, publish public apologies in two national newspapers, on two television stations and on its website, and pay N1 million in costs, with 10 per cent annual interest on the judgment sum until full payment.
The two operatives had sued SERAP and Oluwadare in Suit No. CV/4547/2024, arguing that the claims damaged their personal reputations and the image of the DSS.
In its appeal, SERAP, represented by Tayo Oyetibo, SAN, listed 24 grounds. It argued that the publications did not name the respondents or identify them by rank, designation, office or photograph. The descriptions used, it said, were general physical ones that were not unique to the two officers. SERAP maintained that the respondents failed to call any member of the public or independent witness to show that readers understood the publications to refer to them specifically, and that social-media reactions relied upon were not tendered in evidence.
The organisation further contended that the trial court improperly supplied the missing link of identification by relying on its own observation of the respondents’ appearance in court. SERAP said the award of damages was excessive and arbitrary, and that findings on falsity and justification were not supported by the evidence. It also raised issues concerning the protection of freedom of expression and public-interest advocacy.
The Court of Appeal is yet to fix a date for its judgment.
A story of courage, wonder, and the transformative power of self-belief; perfect for readers aged 10+ who love adventure. To place order: +234 806 130 3237 | +234 803 582 0870 OR Tap the link to grab a copy:https://www.zeekapublish.com/product/the-magical-life-of-anna

